top of page
Sugartoad Cottage Sign



Welcome to this charming couples retreat nestled in the heart of Mathews Main Street! This whole house rental is a peaceful haven that exudes warmth and luxury, providing a comfortable escape for your stay.


Location is key, and the cottage offers the best of both worlds. Situated just a short walk from Main Street, you'll have easy access to a variety of restaurants, shops, events, & activities, but also a serene backyard oasis to retreat to after exploring town.

Book the way you feel comfortable... Avoid fees by booking directly with us.


to the Toad

If you'd like to stay in touch and get notified when we're running giveaways, specials, and other shenanigans, drop us your email.

Thanks for subscribing!



The home features a huge bathroom with brand new washer/dryer, shower and appliances. Spacious living areas including a living room with a 55" smart TV, and fireplace. A dining room for four, and kitchen fully equipped with brand new appliances, retro fridge, large sink, oven and stove, coffee bar, and basic necessities.

For plant lovers - you'll love being surrounded by plants in every room - from window boxes peaking through the 100 year old windows, to ferns and palms on the porches and decks, to sweet little flower pots in every nook and cranny.

Outdoor Deck Sugartoad
Leaves Shadows



Step inside and discover a meticulously decorated space. Every detail has been carefully chosen to create a serene and inviting atmosphere for you to relax comfortably. Sink into the modern comforts of our well-appointed primary bedroom with a king sized bed and trendy decor. This home is a much welcomed place to rest after exciting adventures in our downtown.

Location is Everything


Get the best of both worlds with privacy and convenience. Situated just a short walk from Main Street, you'll have easy access to a variety of delightful restaurants (12 within 1 mile), shops, events, festivals, and museums. Immerse yourself in the local culture and explore the vibrant community surrounding our cottage.

The charm continues as you step onto our inviting front porch, where you can sit and sip your morning coffee or watch the world go by on the rocking chairs. The private backyard includes a deck patio with a picnic table, Solo smokeless stove and fire pit area, edison bulb lighting and privacy fencing. Outdoor shower (coming this summer). 

The cottage's exterior is adorned with vibrant flower plantings and tropical plants, adding a touch of tropical paradise to your stay. Enjoy views of a some of the oldest downtown buildings, murals and light foot traffic to the book store open across the street on Saturdays.

The cottage is a 5 minute drive to Bethel Beach and less than 10 minutes from Gwynn’s Island, Haven Beach,

numerous landings and the New Point Comfort Lighthouse Observation Deck.


This short term rental is catered to couples, and the property is not currently suitable for pets or children.  Explore some of the amenities included below.

bottom of page